John of John by Douglas Stuart: A Heartbreaking Masterpiece That Also Kind of Broke Me (3.5 ⭐)
Rating: 3.5 out of 5 ⭐⭐⭐½
Well, folks, I did it. I finally finished John of John. It only took me roughly three geological eras, two emotional breakdowns, and one very confused cat wondering why I was yelling at a book about sheep. 🐑😭
Douglas Stuart’s 2026 novel is a work of literary fiction set on the remote Isle of Harris in Scotland’s Outer Hebrides, and let me tell you—this book is a lot. It’s beautiful. It’s devastating. It’s also, at times, about as readable as a tax form written in Gaelic. Let’s get into it.
⚠️ Content Triggers & Warnings
Before we dive in, here’s your trigger list because this book does not mess around:
Physical and emotional abuse (including graphic scenes of violence)
Antigay bias and homophobia
Substance use and addiction
Suicidal ideation and suicide attempts
Sexual content
Cursing (lots of it, bless Ella)
Illness and death
Religious trauma (if you grew up in a strict church, prepare thyself)
🚨 Spoiler Warning 🚨
Full, complete spoilers ahead. I’m talking the whole ending, every secret, all the emotional wreckage. If you want to go in blind, scroll down to the recommendations section and pretend you never saw this. 💀
Overview: What’s This Book Actually About?
John of John follows John-Calum “Cal” Macleod, a recent art school graduate who is manipulated into returning to his insular, devoutly religious hometown of Falabay by his father, John. Cal is broke, couch-surfing, and hiding basically everything about himself—his poverty, his sexuality, his general exhaustion with existence—from his father during their weekly stilted phone calls.
John is a precentor (a leader of psalm-singing) in the local Free Presbyterian Church—the “Wee Frees”—and he summons Cal home claiming Cal’s grandmother Ella is ailing. She’s not. Her feet are just cold. Classic emotional manipulation, really. 🫠
The novel is deeply embedded in the unique cultural landscape of the Outer Hebrides: the austere Calvinism, the precarious economies of crofting and Harris Tweed weaving, and the phenomenon of the “islander’s exile,” where young people flee to the mainland for opportunity. Stuart’s own background in fashion and textiles informs the rich, textured detail around weaving, which is genuinely one of the book’s greatest strengths.
📖 Full Plot Summary (With All the Spoilers You Could Ever Want)
Cal arrives home to immediate tension. John criticizes his bleached ginger hair and second-hand clothes, calling him a ceard (vagrant). Cal discovers his father exaggerated Ella’s condition to lure him back. Trapped and in debt, he bristles as John pressures him to work secretly at the family loom—a violation of the weavers’ code that would let them increase output. Visits to his childhood friend Doll Macdonald reveal a bitter, resentful young man struggling with alcohol addiction. Doll is cold to Cal, bitter about being left behind.
Then we get the first big secret: John is gay. He’s been in a decades-long secret relationship with his neighbor Innes MacInnes. Cal’s mother Grace discovered them in a romantic embrace years ago and left, eventually beginning a relationship with John’s brother Uilleam. So that’s a fun family dynamic. 🎭
The tension escalates when John, enraged by Cal’s long hair, rips his jeans before the Sabbath service. Cal attends anyway, drops his Walkman, and later John punches Cal repeatedly in the face. Cal visits his mother, who reveals that Ella plans to legally assign the croft tenancy to her—dispossessing John completely. Cal keeps this secret, deepening the chasm.
Doll’s addiction worsens. He’s publicly shamed by church elders during Communion. Later, at a cèilidh, he has a drunken sexual encounter with an older Irishwoman named Shiv Malone and abandons Cal to freeze outside her B&B. 😤
Feeling isolated, Cal arranges a secret trip to the mainland with Innes under the pretense of helping him buy a van. In an Oban hotel room, Cal attempts to seduce Innes, who gently rejects him—because Innes is in love with John. The next morning, Innes leaves Cal alone. The trip precipitates another violent confrontation at home when John finds Cal wearing Innes’s shirt. After the beating, Ella—who has secretly been learning Gaelic and saving money by withholding church offerings—gives Cal a substantial sum and urges him to leave.
Then tragedy strikes: Doll is found dead on the shore, apparently drowned. 💔
In the aftermath, the community’s grief is compounded when Doll’s sister Isla is revealed to be seven months pregnant. The father is the Glaswegian fisherman who was stranded in the bay months earlier. The church elders, led by Reverend Rose, assume Cal is responsible based on gossip and pressure him to marry Isla. Cal refuses but corroborates Flash’s story about the fisherman.
Ella assigns her tenancy to Grace, revealing to John that she’s long known about him and Innes—and that Cal is also gay. She criticizes the family’s secrecy and lack of communication. John disrupts her plans by revealing the local church is to be sold and the community is threatened by economic precarity.
After learning his estranged brother Uilleam has worsening dementia, John comes to an understanding with Cal. Meanwhile, Innes, heartbroken by John’s inability to commit, finally leaves Falabay—but sends John a QSL card with a meeting time and place in Portree that evening, offering one last chance. Cal seizes the moment, framing Innes’s departure as a crisis of faith. He urges his father to follow Innes under the guise of a missionary trip—a lie that provides John with a respectable way to pursue his own happiness.
As John secures passage on Donnie’s boat, Cal frantically packs his father’s belongings and, fearing John will be too late, calls a grocer in Portree with a desperate message for Innes: wait.
With his own escape route given over to his father, Cal finds new purpose. He gives Ella’s money to Isla, allowing her to escape to Glasgow with her newborn son. He then uses the remaining cash to buy Doll’s broken-down Ford Capri from Donnie, creating a fragile peace between the families.
In the suddenly empty house, with both John and Ella gone, Cal is alone for the first time. The quiet is broken by Ishbel, the bellwether ewe, who wanders into the kitchen. Looking at the sheep his grandmother claimed was her spy in the community, Cal embraces his new role. He strokes the ewe’s muzzle and asks her to deliver a message, asking his grandmother to come home. 🐑✨
My Thoughts: The Good, The Bad, and The Weirdly Incestuous
What Worked 💖
The emotional core is devastating. Stuart knows how to gut you. The father-son relationship is complex and painful, and the parallel journeys of John and Cal—both closeted, both trapped by religion and community, both unable to communicate—are genuinely heartbreaking. The moment Cal realizes his father is in love with Innes and unable to be honest about his sexuality is gut-wrenching.
The writing is gorgeous. Stuart’s prose is precise, evocative, and often stunning. The way he describes weaving, color, and the Hebridean landscape is genuinely masterful. You can feel the wind and the salt and the wool.
Ella is a treasure. The foul-mouthed Glaswegian grandmother who secretly learns Gaelic by eavesdropping and saves money by withholding church offerings? Iconic. She’s the comic relief this bleak novel desperately needs, and her relationship with Cal is genuinely warm.
What Didn’t Work 😬
It’s too damn long. This book is 416 pages and feels like 800. There’s a lot of fluffy pages—meandering descriptions, repetitive internal monologue, and scenes that don’t meaningfully advance the plot. I found myself skimming entire sections just to get to the next thing that actually mattered. The pacing is sluggish, especially in the middle third.
The "incestuous undertones" are genuinely weird. Cal’s attraction to Innes—his father’s secret lover—creates a deeply uncomfortable dynamic that doesn’t contribute meaningfully to the story. It’s not that it’s taboo; it’s that it feels gratuitous. It muddies Cal’s characterization and adds a layer of ick that the novel never properly addresses or resolves. The whole time I was like… why is this here? 🤨
It’s not always very readable. Stuart’s commitment to authentic Gaelic dialogue and dense, dialect-heavy prose is admirable from a craft perspective, but it made this book genuinely difficult to get through at times. I’m not unfamiliar with Scottish literature, but there were sentences I had to read three times just to parse.
The “similar ground” feeling is real. If you’ve read Shuggie Bain or Young Mungo, you know Stuart’s themes: queerness, working-class life, repression, family dysfunction, Scotland. John of John doesn’t break new thematic ground—it’s a variation on a theme. That’s not necessarily bad, but it does make the book feel less urgent than his debut.
The Rating Struggle 🤔
Here’s the thing: it feels almost wrong to give a book like this a low rating. The subject matter is heavy, the emotional impact is real, and Stuart is clearly a talented writer. But I refuse to let subject matter guilt me into inflating my rating. A book can tackle important themes AND still be a slog to get through. Both things can be true.
I was impressed by John of John. I was also relieved when it was over.
3.5 stars. Rounding down because I want to be honest: this is a good book that could have been a great one with tighter editing.
📚 If You Liked John of John, Try These:
Shuggie Bain by Douglas Stuart — Obviously. His Booker-winning debut. More focused, more devastating, more readable.
Young Mungo by Douglas Stuart — His second novel. Similar themes, tighter execution.
The Lost Language of Cranes by David Leavitt — Stuart cited this as an influence. A classic of gay literary fiction.
Gilead by Marilynne Robinson — Another Stuart influence. A quiet, contemplative novel about fathers and sons and faith.
Amongst Women by John McGahern — The third influence Stuart named. A family drama set in rural Ireland.
Sunset Song by Lewis Grassic Gibbon — If you want more Scottish landscape and a young protagonist yearning for escape.
Final Verdict
John of John is a beautiful, heartbreaking, frustrating, and occasionally tedious novel. It’s worth reading for the emotional payoff and Stuart’s gorgeous prose, but be prepared for a slow, meandering journey to get there. And maybe have a palate cleanser ready for afterward. Something light. Like a comedy. Or a nap. 😴
3.5 stars. Would I read Stuart’s next book? Probably. But I’d check the page count first. 📏
Comments
Post a Comment