Mrs. Everything Review: A Big, Messy Family Saga That Somehow Works ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4/5 Stars)
There are books that focus on one thing and do it really well.
Then there are books like Mrs. Everything that decide, "You know what? Let's tackle... everything." 😂
And somehow... it mostly works.
I really enjoyed this novel. It's emotional, funny, frustrating, heartbreaking, inspiring, and occasionally exhausting because it tries to cram about fifty years of American social history into one family story. There were definitely moments where I thought, Okay Jennifer Weiner, maybe we can save one or two issues for another novel? 😅
But despite trying to do so much, I never stopped caring about these characters.
📚 Rating
⭐⭐⭐⭐ 4/5 stars
⚠️ Trigger Warnings
Child sexual abuse
Sexual assault
Rape
Drug use and addiction
Illegal abortion
Homophobia
Infidelity
Racism
Cancer
Death of a parent
Terminal illness
Miscarriage/pregnancy-related themes
🚨 Spoiler Warning
This review contains FULL spoilers, including the ending.
If you haven't read Mrs. Everything, now is your chance to escape. 🏃♀️💨
📖 Plot Summary
Mrs. Everything follows sisters Jo and Bethie Kaufman, spanning roughly seventy years from the 1950s into the 2020s. It's a sweeping family saga that explores changing expectations for women, sexuality, motherhood, marriage, race, feminism, and what it really means to live an authentic life.
Growing up in Detroit, the sisters couldn't be more different.
Jo is athletic, stubborn, and a classic tomboy. She hates dresses, loves basketball, and constantly disappoints her traditional mother, Sarah, who desperately wishes Jo would become the proper housewife society expects. Their father, Ken, however, encourages Jo to be herself and is by far the more supportive parent.
Meanwhile, Bethie is everything their mother dreams of. She enjoys cooking, sewing, performing, and tries very hard to be the "good daughter."
Their childhood changes dramatically when Ken unexpectedly dies of a heart attack. Suddenly Sarah must support the family by working long hours, leaving the girls largely to navigate adolescence on their own.
Things become far darker when Bethie babysits for their Uncle Mel. He repeatedly sexually abuses her, leaving her traumatized and ashamed. Bethie gains weight and withdraws into herself, unable to tell anyone until Jo eventually returns from summer camp. Jo believes her immediately and, in one of the novel's most satisfying moments, blackmails Uncle Mel into repaying money he owed Ken in exchange for their silence. It's far from justice, but it's the only power two young women have in that era.
As young adults, the sisters head in very different directions.
Jo attends college, becomes involved in the women's rights movement, and falls deeply in love with fellow activist Shelley. For the first time, she allows herself to fully embrace being a lesbian. Unfortunately, Shelley ultimately chooses the safer, socially acceptable path by secretly getting engaged to a man. Heartbroken, Jo ends the relationship.
Bethie, meanwhile, embraces the counterculture movement. She experiments heavily with drugs and travels with friends to a music festival. During a bad LSD trip, she's brutally gang-raped by four men. She becomes pregnant and contracts an STI. After her boyfriend abandons her, Jo once again steps in, arranging an illegal abortion through Shelley's contacts.
Trying to escape her trauma, Bethie spends years traveling, singing, dealing drugs, and searching for herself.
Ironically, Jo—who spent years rejecting society's expectations—begins moving toward exactly the life she never wanted.
At Shelley's wedding, she meets Dave, a funny and charming man. Exhausted from constantly fighting prejudice and rejection, Jo convinces herself she can build a happy life with a man. They marry quickly and have three daughters: Kim, Missy, and Lila.
For a while, life appears stable.
But appearances are deceiving.
Jo never truly stops loving women, and Dave proves increasingly irresponsible. He mishandles their finances, drives the family toward bankruptcy, and eventually has an affair with Jo's friend, Nonie.
When Dave and Nonie steal Jo's successful fitness routine to create their own workout video, Jo sues them and wins. The lawsuit gives her the financial independence she has never had.
At last, Jo decides she's done pretending.
She leaves Dave and finally reunites with Shelley, who has also divorced. Decades after first falling in love, the two finally get the future they should have had all along.
Meanwhile, Bethie eventually reconnects with her high school crush, Harold, a kind Black man she had admired years earlier. The two marry, settle in Atlanta, and transform a women's commune into a successful jam business and bed-and-breakfast.
The novel eventually shifts toward Jo's adult daughters.
Each woman struggles with different expectations placed on modern women.
Kim becomes a successful lawyer but feels guilty for not being the stay-at-home mother her husband wanted.
Missy builds an impressive publishing career but ignores serious sexual harassment because speaking up might destroy everything she's worked for.
Lila spends years drifting from job to job before unexpectedly becoming pregnant.
Watching her daughters wrestle with many of the same impossible expectations she faced decades earlier, Jo realizes that progress has been made—but not nearly enough.
Then comes the devastating final act.
Jo develops breast cancer.
She beats it once, giving everyone hope.
Ten years later, however, the cancer returns.
Knowing she doesn't have much time left, Jo spends her remaining days surrounded by the people she loves most: Shelley, Bethie, Harold, and her daughters.
Rather than offering perfect answers, she encourages her daughters to stop chasing impossible standards of motherhood and womanhood. She reminds them they're doing better than they think.
Eventually, Jo dies peacefully, leaving behind a family that has finally learned to accept each other for who they truly are.
❤️ What I Loved
The biggest strength of Mrs. Everything is unquestionably its characters.
Even though the novel covers decades and an enormous cast, I always cared about what happened to Jo and Bethie.
There are genuinely funny moments mixed in with absolutely heartbreaking ones. I laughed several times, then found myself wiping away tears a few chapters later. That's not an easy balance to pull off.
I also appreciated how the novel shows just how dramatically life changed for women over the second half of the twentieth century. Reading Jo's story really makes you appreciate how much courage it took simply to be yourself during that era.
🤔 What Didn't Quite Work
My biggest criticism is that this book sometimes feels like it's trying to become the encyclopedia of women's experiences.
It covers:
Sexuality
Feminism
Civil rights
Homophobia
Marriage
Motherhood
Career struggles
Sexual assault
Child abuse
Drug culture
Cancer
Infidelity
Body image
Aging
Family relationships
...and probably a dozen more topics I'm forgetting. 😅
Individually, these storylines are interesting. Together, they occasionally make the novel feel overloaded.
Sometimes I wished it had slowed down and spent even more time developing a few of its strongest storylines instead of introducing yet another major life event.
💕 A Personal Thought
Oddly enough, what stayed with me most wasn't the politics or even the romance.
It was the parenting.
Watching Jo constantly worry whether she'd failed her daughters made me think about my own kids.
I already know they're wonderful, but this book made me want to hug them anyway and remind them just how proud I am of them. ❤️
Raising children is exhausting. It's messy. You second-guess yourself constantly.
But books like this remind you that, despite all the chaos, it's absolutely worth it.
📚 Final Thoughts
Mrs. Everything is ambitious, emotional, funny, frustrating, and incredibly human.
Does it try to do too much?
Absolutely.
Did I still enjoy the journey?
Also absolutely.
If you're looking for a sweeping family saga full of memorable characters and decades of changing social expectations, this is an engaging read—even if it occasionally bites off more than it can chew.
Final Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4/5 stars)
📖 Books I'd Recommend If You Enjoyed Mrs. Everything
❤️ The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo — Taylor Jenkins Reid
❤️ The Great Alone — Kristin Hannah
❤️ The Dutch House — Ann Patchett
❤️ Little Fires Everywhere — Celeste Ng
❤️ The Most Fun We Ever Had — Claire Lombardo
❤️ Ask Again, Yes — Mary Beth Keane
❤️ The Paper Palace — Miranda Cowley Heller
Comments
Post a Comment