The Wrong Daughter by Dandy Smith

on


 

⭐⭐⭐☆☆ The Wrong Daughter Review: A Wild Ride That Needed a Reality Check

📚 Overview

The Wrong Daughter (2025) by Dandy Smith is a psychological thriller centered on Caitlin Arden, a woman whose life has been shaped by the disappearance of her older sister, Olivia, sixteen years earlier. When a woman claiming to be Olivia suddenly returns, Caitlin begins to question everything—her memories, her family, and whether the woman who came back is truly her sister. As suspicions grow, long-buried secrets begin to surface, forcing Caitlin to confront what really happened the night Olivia vanished.

⚠️ Trigger Warnings

  • Child abduction

  • Violence & murder

  • Physical & emotional abuse

  • Incest

  • Mental illness

  • Suicide

  • Substance use

😬 My Honest Thoughts

Let’s start with the good:

✔️ Great premise
✔️ Strong twists
✔️ Moments that are genuinely unputdownable

BUT…

This book goes from intriguing → questionable → completely unhinged 😅

🤯 The Biggest Issue: It’s Just Too Much

I get it. Thrillers stretch reality. That’s part of the fun.

But this?
👉 Way too farfetched

And not in a fun, wink-at-the-reader way like Freida McFadden sometimes pulls off.

Instead, it just keeps escalating until you’re like:

  • “Okay… sure… I guess we’re doing this now??” 🙃

  • “Wait, ANOTHER twist???”

  • “Why is this so complicated???”

🔄 The POV Problem

Multiple POVs can be great.

Here? Not so much.

  • It felt convoluted

  • It dragged the story out

  • It made everything more confusing than it needed to be

Instead of adding depth, it just made the book feel… longer. And not in a good way.

⏳ The Pacing

This is a slow burn that suddenly chugs an energy drink at 80% 🚀

That’s when it finally becomes:
👉 completely unputdownable

Unfortunately, that’s ALSO when:
👉 the story goes fully off the rails

So yes, I was glued to it… but also questioning every life choice that led me there 😂

⚠️ SPOILER WARNING ⚠️

Full plot + ending below!

🧵 Full Plot Summary (With Spoilers)

🧒 The Abduction

Sixteen years ago, Caitlin witnesses her sister Olivia being abducted by a masked man.

Gone without a trace.

👀 Present Day: The Return

Out of nowhere… Olivia comes back.

But something is off:

  • She doesn’t remember key details

  • She acts strangely

  • Caitlin is convinced she’s an impostor

No one believes her. Of course 🙃

🧩 Parallel Storyline (aka where things start getting messy)

We’re introduced to:

  • Elinor and Heath

  • Creepy mansion vibes

  • Murder, abuse, and escalating chaos

Eventually:
👉 Heath kills Elinor
👉 And things take a DARK turn

💣 Everything Explodes

Back in Caitlin’s timeline:

  • Her fiancé Oscar turns out to be connected to the case 😬

  • The “boy on the bus”?? Yeah… that’s him

  • He’s writing a book about it (because why not make things worse)

Meanwhile:

  • Olivia gets more suspicious

  • Caitlin spirals

  • Everyone thinks Caitlin is the problem

😳 The Big Reveal

Here’s where it goes FULL chaos:

👉 Olivia is NOT an impostor
👉 She is the real Olivia

BUT—

She is:

  • In love with her kidnapper 😳

  • Working with him

  • Fully complicit

The kidnapper?

👉 Heath.
👉 Who has been pretending to be Caitlin’s therapist.

Yes. Really.

🔪 Final Showdown

Caitlin is kidnapped and taken to the mansion.

  • Another captive (Bryony) is there

  • Heath plans to stage Caitlin’s suicide

  • Olivia wants Caitlin there (because… reasons)

Caitlin fights back:
👉 Kills Heath with a marble bust

Then:
👉 Olivia attacks her
👉 Bryony pushes Olivia off a roof

And that’s the end of that.

🕊️ Ending

One year later:

  • Caitlin is healing

  • Relationships are… semi-repaired

  • She’s finally moving forward

💭 Final Thoughts

This book had:
✨ So much potential
✨ Some REALLY good twists

But ultimately:
👉 It tried to do way too much

Instead of being shocking, it became:
👉 overcomplicated and unbelievable

Still, I can’t deny:
👉 I was entertained 👀

⭐ 3 stars

📖 If You Like Messy, Twisty Thrillers:

This is one of those books where I kept reading because I needed to know what happened…
even if I was rolling my eyes a little by the end 😅

Comments

Post a Comment