James by Percival Everett
⭐ 2/5 — James by Percival Everett: The Book Everyone Waited For (But I’m Still Trying to Digest)
📚 Get James by Percival Everett on Amazon (affiliate link)
⚠️ Trigger Warnings
Racism, racial slurs (including the n-word), enslavement, anti-Black violence, sexual abuse (referenced), and systemic oppression.
🪶 Initial Thoughts
Let me start by saying: I really wanted to love this book. I’d been on my Libby waitlist for what felt like an eternity — and everyone seemed to adore it. It’s one of the most acclaimed novels of 2024, and people keep calling it a modern classic. So my expectations? Sky-high.
But… I didn’t love it. 😬
To be fair, I admire it. Everett’s writing is powerful, smart, and intentionally challenging. Still, I found it dense and difficult to follow, maybe because I’m not used to his style. I’ve also never read The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, so I probably missed some of the clever callbacks.
I’m honestly a little nervous even admitting this (book Twitter can be feral 😂), but this wasn’t a page-turner for me. I respect it, I see why it’s important — but enjoyment-wise? 3 out of 5 stars.
🌀 Spoiler Warning
This review includes full spoilers — ending and all. Proceed only if you want everything laid bare! 👇
🧭 Overview
James (2024) by Percival Everett is a bold retelling of Mark Twain’s The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn from the point of view of Jim — here revealed to be James, a man far more educated, articulate, and self-aware than history ever allowed him to be.
Everett flips the entire story on its head. What Twain told as a folksy moral adventure about a white boy helping a runaway slave, Everett retells as a brutal, ironic, deeply human account of enslavement, identity, and survival.
James speaks polished English among other enslaved people, but drops into dialect around whites — a survival tactic that hides his intellect from those who’d punish him for it.
📖 Full Plot Summary (with Spoilers)
The novel begins in Hannibal, Missouri, where James serves Miss Watson and lives with his wife Lizzie and daughter Sadie. When he learns that Miss Watson plans to sell him, he flees under cover of night, hiding on a small island in the Mississippi.
There he encounters Huck Finn, a boy escaping his violent father Pap Finn. Despite their differences, the two form an unlikely bond and set out on a raft down the river — James hoping for freedom, Huck for safety.
As they travel, Huck begins to see James as human for the first time, though Everett makes clear that James is the true leader, steering the boat, outsmarting pursuers, and navigating the moral chaos of their world.
They encounter slave-catchers, con men (“the King” and “the Duke”), and violent towns that test both their courage and their humanity. Through it all, James records his experiences in secret, hoping one day his words will outlive him.
🎭 The Middle Acts
At one point, James is forced into a minstrel troupe led by a white showman named Emmett, where he must sing in blackface — a horrifying irony Everett uses to skewer how America commodifies Black pain. James eventually escapes with another man, Norman, who has been “passing” as white.
Their attempt at freedom ends in tragedy when Norman dies during a steamboat accident. James later reunites with Huck, and their friendship — already strained by fear and misunderstanding — takes on a shocking new depth.
💥 The Twist: James Is Huck’s Father
In a quiet, emotionally devastating reveal, James tells Huck that he is his biological father.
We learn that Huck’s mother and James had a relationship years earlier, when they were young. Their connection crossed every social and racial boundary of their time. The revelation reframes everything we’ve read: James’s deep protectiveness toward Huck, his patience, his heartbreak at the boy’s ignorance — all of it becomes the tragic devotion of a father who cannot claim his own son.
This twist demolishes the foundation of Twain’s original. The “boy and slave” duo the world romanticized are, in truth, father and son — an unacknowledged family split apart by America’s lies about race and ownership.
Everett’s point lands hard: the entire country is built on hidden kinship and denied parentage, where white freedom and Black suffering share the same bloodline.
🔥 The Ending
After revealing the truth, James risks everything to rescue Lizzie and Sadie, who have been sold away. In a breathtaking finale, he sets a fire to cover their escape and leads them north. They reach Iowa — “free,” but not truly equal — where the family must start over under suspicion and hostility.
The book ends somberly. James knows his story will be rewritten — turned into someone else’s tale (Huck Finn, anyone?). Still, he insists on writing his truth, leaving readers with a haunting meditation on who gets to tell America’s stories.
💬 My Thoughts
I totally understand why critics love this book — it’s layered, brilliant, and bold. It forces readers to rethink what they thought they knew about a “classic.” But for me? It was more intellectually fascinating than emotionally gripping.
I struggled with the pacing and the density of Everett’s prose. Some passages left me rereading sentences three times like, “Wait… what just happened?” 😅
That said, the twist blew me away. The father-son revelation made me rethink not just the book, but the entire idea of what “freedom” and “family” mean in a world built on injustice.
⭐ Rating: 2/5
Interesting. Important. Admirable. But … a bit of a slog for me.
If you love literary fiction, historical retellings, or stories that dissect American mythology with surgical precision, this might be your perfect match. If you want an easy emotional ride — maybe not.
📚 If You Liked This Book, You Might Also Enjoy
-
The Underground Railroad by Colson Whitehead
-
Kindred by Octavia E. Butler
-
The Heaven & Earth Grocery Store by James McBride
-
Song of Solomon by Toni Morrison
✨ Thanks for reading! If you’ve read James, I’d love to hear your take — did the twist floor you or lose you completely? Drop a comment below and let’s chat! 💬
Comments
Post a Comment