The Heaven & Earth Grocery Store by James McBride

 

---

⭐ 1-Star Review: The Heaven & Earth Grocery Store by James McBride

🎭 Historical Fiction meets Mystery, then they forget to text each other back.

📌 Spoiler Warning!
This review contains full, detailed spoilers. I'm talking ending, twists, trauma, and the kitchen sink. If you’re planning to read this book and want to stay surprised (and maybe enjoy it more than I did), bookmark this and come back later. Otherwise... let’s dive into the mess. 🕳️💀

---

📚 Book Overview

• Title: The Heaven & Earth Grocery Store

• Author: James McBride

• Genre: Adult Historical Fiction / Mystery

• Published: 2023

• Rating: ⭐ 1 out of 5 stars

• Amazon Link: Buy it here if you must 💸

---

⚠️ Trigger Warnings

👉 Please be advised that this book contains:

• Racism / White supremacy

• Police brutality

• Sexual assault of a child

• Institutional abuse

• Death of a child

• Anti-Semitism

• Seizures and medical trauma

• Murder

• Animal cruelty (brief)

• Ableism

• Misogyny

Not a light read, and definitely not a cozy one either. 😬

---

🕳️ The Premise: Skeletons in Wells and Promises of Mystery!

When I picked up The Heaven & Earth Grocery Store, I thought I was getting a brilliant mystery. A skeleton found in a well? In a small town with secrets? YES PLEASE. Sign me up. But then... it kind of just... meanders into a 400-page TED Talk about community, racism, and perseverance. 😐

Important? Sure. But engaging? Ehhhhhh...

---

🧠 Plot Summary (FULL SPOILERS!)

🗓️ 1972 — Cops discover a skeleton in a well in Chicken Hill, a marginalized neighborhood in Pottstown, PA. Hurricane Agnes hits the next day, wiping out the evidence. Mysterious! Juicy! Let's go! 🎣

⏳ Flashback 1920s-30s — We’re suddenly taken back 47 years to learn about Chona and Moshe Ludlow, a Jewish couple running the Heaven & Earth Grocery Store. She’s generous and beloved, he’s grumpy and confused by her compassion. Chona eventually becomes terminally ill, but the Black community rallies around her while the white doctors shrug.

👦 Enter Dodo, a 12-year-old Black boy who is deaf. The state wants to institutionalize him because he’s “different.” Chona and Moshe hide him in their apartment like he’s Anne Frank with sign language.

💥 Then the plot SNAPS into horror mode.
Dr. Roberts — who is both a physician and a Ku Klux Klan member (because of course he is 🙄) — finds out about Dodo and bursts into the store. He assaults Chona while she's having a seizure (!!!), Dodo jumps in to help, but ends up injured and institutionalized.

🏥 At Pennhurst, Dodo meets a disabled boy he names Monkey Pants. They become fast friends. Unfortunately, they also encounter “Son of Man,” an attendant who sexually abuses children. Monkey Pants saves Dodo by intervening, but dies from a seizure during the attack. 😢

🔪 Dodo’s uncle, Nate Timblin, a reformed ex-con (aka Nate Love), goes full vigilante and murders Son of Man in the institution using a kitchen knife. Frankly, it’s the most satisfying part of the book.

🕯️ Chona dies.
💧 Moshe mourns.
🏃 Nate and Addie Timblin rescue Dodo and flee to South Carolina.
🪦 Doc Roberts? Poetic justice incoming. He keeps the mezuzah he stole from Chona as a trophy, tries to dispose of it in the well, and gets mistaken for a corrupt city councilman. A mobster’s henchman breaks his jaw and throws him down the well. 💀 (Hello, skeleton mystery from the prologue! Remember that? Barely.)

🌅 Epilogue: Dodo lives a long life under the name Nate Love II, in honor of his brave uncle. He becomes a patriarch of a sprawling family, presumably never mentioning that the book he starred in was 80% atmospheric side quests. 😐

---

😩 My Thoughts

Am I reading the same book as the internet? Because everyone is calling this “a modern classic” and I just... can’t.

Yes, McBride writes with heart, and I respect the themes of community, racial justice, and unlikely alliances — but this book was a slog. It forgot its own premise, introduced way too many characters, and delivered powerful moments with zero momentum. And somehow, it took all the ingredients for a gripping tale — murder, mystery, injustice, redemption — and still managed to be... kind of boring.

Not to mention, I waited the whole book to care about that dang skeleton in the well. When we finally got the payoff, it felt like a footnote.

---

😐 Final Verdict

I wanted to love this. I really did. But in the end, it felt like reading a novel where everyone is talking, but nobody is telling the story you were promised. ⭐ 1 out of 5 stars.

---

🛒 Buy It (If You Must)

👉 The Heaven & Earth Grocery Store on Amazon
💵 I’d recommend borrowing it from the library first. Just saying.

---

📚 You Might Like These Instead...

If you want historical fiction that actually keeps you engaged, try these:

• The Book Thief by Markus Zusak — WWII setting, unforgettable narrator, and real heart

• The Women by Kristin Hannah — gripping, emotional, and sharply written

• The Nickel Boys by Colson Whitehead — also explores institutional abuse, but tightly paced and powerful

• The Night Watchman by Louise Erdrich — historical, political, and character-driven but never dull

• Deacon King Kong by James McBride — maybe try this one instead? It’s widely praised and far more lively

---

✍️ Let’s Discuss!

Did I miss something? Did you love this book? Are you as confused by the hype as I am?
💬 Drop your thoughts in the comments!