You Shouldn't Have Come Here by Jeneva Rose
🔪 You Shouldn’t Have Come Here by Jeneva Rose
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️½ (4.5 out of 5 stars) | Genre: Psychological Thriller | Tropes: Airbnb Horror, Small-Town Secrets, Femme Fatale With a Twist
💭 What happens when a luxury-loving New York banker books an isolated Wyoming Airbnb for some me time and instead ends up in a Lifetime movie…?
You get You Shouldn’t Have Come Here—a book that lures you in with cowboy charm and then stabs you in the gut with a hunting knife. And honestly? I loved it.
Jeneva Rose doesn’t just meet expectations here—she lassos them, drags them through the pasture, and buries them next to some unsettling guestbook entries. This is psychological suspense with a dark twist that had me flipping pages like I was swatting at bees.
🛻 The Setup: Banker Meets Cowboy
Our main character, Grace Evans, is a high-powered banker from NYC who books a random ranch Airbnb in Wind River, Wyoming, to decompress from her stress-loaded job. She picks the location by literally pointing at a map. (Note to self: maybe don’t vacation like it’s a game of blindfolded darts.)
Before she even makes it to the ranch, creepy gas station guy gives her weird vibes. Rightfully so—he stares too long and follows her to her car. Red flag #1.
When she arrives at the Airbnb, she meets Calvin Wells, the cowboy host who’s rugged, broody, helpful, and too hot for the zip code. Naturally, Grace is skeptical at first... until she isn’t.
The ranch is beautiful but isolated AF, and there’s no cell service or internet, which Grace kind of just… accepts. Honestly, for a successful New Yorker, her red-flag radar is surprisingly offline.
🚩 Let the Creepy Begin
Within hours, things get weird:
-
Grace sees blood on a window and a pair of women’s underwear lying around. Calvin casually explains it all away—“Oh, that? Just remnants of my dead girlfriend, Lisa.”
-
She hears screaming at night. Calvin shrugs: “Probably just a fox.”
-
Sheriff Almond shows up to say a woman named Briana Becker went missing on her way to this very ranch. Calvin swears she never arrived.
-
Grace’s car breaks down. Calvin’s shady brother Joe, a mechanic, is the only one who can “fix” it.
And yet… Grace keeps sleeping with the guy. (To be fair, he gives her back rubs and chocolates, so naturally, any woman would be like: “Murderer? Hmm, maybe not.”)
Meanwhile, Charlotte, a jealous friend of Calvin’s, keeps trying to scare Grace away. (Honestly, Charlotte is the town MVP. Girl tried.)
🔥 The Tension Hits a Boil
Then comes Albert—a new “guest” at the ranch who randomly climbs into Grace’s bed at night. She freaks, understandably, and demands Calvin install a lock. He does… but backwards. Suspicious? Extremely.
Grace goes full amateur sleuth:
-
She sneaks into the off-limits basement and finds a photo linking Albert to Calvin as his uncle, along with a guestbook showing Briana was there.
-
She discovers Albert’s body dumped near the beehives, despite his known bee allergy.
-
She’s terrified, but not terrified enough to leave until her car is fixed. (Still waiting on Joe, everyone. 🙄)
Then comes Betty, Calvin’s surrogate mother, who ominously says: “You shouldn’t have come here.” (👀 Title drop! Always a fun time.)
🧨 The Explosive Climax (Literally)
Calvin wakes up the next morning to find Grace is almost gone. But he’s already been poisoned by the drugged coffee she made. (Oops.)
Grace confronts him and, in full thriller glory, he confesses to murdering Lisa and keeping Briana captive in the shed.
So Grace does what any self-respecting thriller heroine (with secrets of her own) would do:
-
Kills Calvin with a hunting knife
-
Burns the place down
-
Frees Briana
-
Drives away in Calvin’s truck like it’s a casual Tuesday
Except…
😱 Surprise! Grace isn’t Grace.
At the end, we learn that Grace Evans is actually Avery Adams, and she’s not just a vacationing banker. She’s a cold-blooded serial killer who just took out a fellow psychopath.
She stops by that same gas station from the beginning, where the attendant recognizes her. Uh oh. So she blows the place up. Because why not.
Then she drops the truck in Nebraska, rents a car back to Illinois, and returns to her adoring husband and two kids, as if she didn’t just kill two people and rescue a hostage. She keeps Calvin’s hunting knife as a souvenir and muses that her daughter Margo might become like her someday. How sweet. 💀
✏️ Final Thoughts
This book? Absolutely wild.
And that twist? I didn't see it coming. It’s Gone Girl meets The Guest List with a splash of You and a cowboy hat.
If you love thrillers where you root for the killer without realizing it, this one’s for you. It’s twisty, fast-paced, a little ridiculous, but honestly—so much fun.
🛒 Buy You Shouldn’t Have Come Here:
📚 Love this vibe? Here are more books you’ll probably devour:
-
The Housemaid by Freida McFadden – Because you love it when people have no clue who they’re living with.
-
The Last Mrs. Parrish by Liv Constantine – Glamorous women, dark secrets, and major twists.
-
The Perfect Marriage by Jeneva Rose – Her other hit and just as juicy.
So tell me—did you see the twist coming? Or were you screaming “WAIT, WHAT?” like I was?
Let’s talk creepy ranches, suspicious coffee, and secret psychopaths. 🧠🔪
Comments
Post a Comment