Hemlock & Silver by T. Kingfisher

-


Hemlock & Silver by T. Kingfisher — ⭐⭐ 2/5 Stars | Mirror Apples, Murderous Reflections & My Ongoing Kingfisher Dilemma

Well.

This was… not it. 😐

At this point I need to stop pretending that maybe this will be the T. Kingfisher book that converts me. She’s wildly beloved. People adore her. Nettle & Bone won awards. The fanbase is strong. And yet here I am again, finishing one of her books thinking, “Why am I doing this to myself?”

Hemlock & Silver is a Snow White–inspired fantasy mystery about poison, mirrors, and moral gray areas.

On paper? Amazing.
In execution? I struggled.

⚠️ Content Warnings

  • Graphic violence

  • Illness & wasting disease

  • Child death

  • Murder

  • Animal death (poison testing)

  • Emotional abuse

  • Self-harm references

  • Substance use

  • Mental illness

  • Addiction

📖 Overview

Hemlock & Silver (2025) follows Anja, a scholar of poisons and antidotes, who is summoned by a king to diagnose his daughter Snow’s mysterious illness. What begins as a suspected case of slow poisoning turns into a supernatural conspiracy involving a fully functioning mirror-world.

The novel explores:

  • Scientific skepticism vs. superstition

  • Identity and reflection

  • Morality beyond fairy-tale binaries

It’s thoughtful. It’s layered. It’s clever.

It is also… slow. 🫠

🚨 SPOILER WARNING 🚨

Full plot and ending below.

🧪 Murder Confession, But Make It Casual

The book opens with the widowed king showing up in Anja’s stillroom and confessing that he murdered his wife.

You know. As one does.

He claims he caught her cutting out the heart of their daughter, Rose. He killed her on the spot. Rose died. Now his surviving daughter, 12-year-old Snow, is wasting away from a mysterious illness.

He suspects poison.

Anja agrees to investigate at the royal estate, Witherleaf, after securing protection for her family.

We also learn why Anja studies poisons: as a child, her cousin died after eating poison hemlock he mistook for wild carrot. The lack of a cure shaped her entire life’s work. Honestly? That backstory was compelling and grounded in a way the rest of the book sometimes wasn’t.

🍎 The Silver Apple Situation

At Witherleaf, Snow is pale, weak, vomiting — but doesn’t match any known poison symptoms.

Then Anja catches her hiding a strange silvery apple.

Anja tests it on a rooster (no effect), then eats some herself (bold move). It tastes unnaturally cold.

Soon after, she follows a one-eyed cat through a mirror and falls into a cold, nearly colorless duplicate of the real world.

Yes. We are in Mirror Land now. 🪞

The apple is “mirror-food.” It allows someone to pass through silver into this reflection world — but it also poisons them in the real world.

Mystery solved?

Not even close.

👑 The Mirror Queen Reveal

Snow confesses she’s been eating the apples because a mysterious woman is holding her sister Rose captive in the mirror-world and promises to return her.

Eventually, the truth unfolds:

  • The villain is the Mirror Queen, the awakened reflection of the king’s dead wife.

  • The real queen accidentally “woke” her reflection with blood.

  • Reflections can permanently enter the real world only by consuming their real counterpart’s heart.

  • Mirror Queen killed the real Rose and fed her heart to Mirror Rose.

  • The real queen discovered the swap and tried to cut out Mirror Rose’s heart.

  • The king walked in mid-chaos and killed his wife, believing she was murdering their child.

So yes — he killed the wrong person while trying to stop what he thought was the wrong crime. It’s tragic. It’s messy. It’s very fairy tale.

Meanwhile, Snow’s longtime nurse — guilt-ridden over Rose’s earlier behavioral decline — has been manipulated into helping Snow access the apples. She genuinely believes she’s protecting the child, not poisoning her.

Nobody here is making good decisions.

🪞 Final Showdown & Ending

Snow overdoses on mirror-food in order to gain enough strength to physically shove the Mirror Queen into the real world.

Anja and Javier confront the Queen in the mirror realm. Using two mirrors and a massive mirror-geld (a creature formed from fractured reflections), they trap and fracture the Queen’s image.

Snow tackles her through the mirror.

Because the real queen is dead, the Mirror Queen has no anchor. She dissolves into dust.

Snow collapses into a deathlike coma from the overdose.

Anja revives her using an antidote derived from adder venom (finally, the toxicology payoff 👏).

The nurse confesses her involvement and quietly leaves the estate rather than facing public ruin.

Anja and Javier acknowledge their feelings and decide to leave together so he can become her guard and partner.

Mirror world sealed. Evil reflection dusted. Science wins.

The end.

🤔 Why It Didn’t Work For Me

Here’s the thing.

The ideas are strong. The mirror mechanics are inventive. The toxicology angle is genuinely interesting.

But I never felt pulled in.

The pacing is slow.
The emotional beats felt muted.
The romance barely sparked.
The tension never really tightened.

I kept reading not because I was hooked — but because I wanted to see how the mechanics resolved.

And for me, fantasy has to absorb you. If I’m not transported, it’s hard to care how clever the worldbuilding is.

Maybe if I loved quieter, idea-driven fantasy more, this would have landed better. But as it stands?

I think it’s time for me to officially retire from my “Maybe this T. Kingfisher will be the one” era. 😅

📚 If You Want a Stronger Fairy-Tale Retelling

If you’re craving a retelling with more atmosphere or emotional pull, try:

  • Spinning Silver by Naomi Novik

  • The Bear and the Nightingale by Katherine Arden

  • House of Salt and Sorrows by Erin A. Craig

  • Nettle & Bone by T. Kingfisher

Final Thoughts

⭐ 2 out of 5 stars

Not terrible. Not offensive. Just… not absorbing.

Clever concept. Cool mirrors. Solid science.

But I need a fantasy to make me forget I’m reading.

This one just kept reminding me I was. 🪞🍎

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular Posts This Week!

When the Cranes Fly South by Lisa Ridzén

-
Image
  ⭐️⭐️⭐️ (3/5) — WHEN THE CRANES FLY SOUTH : A Beautiful, Heavy Story I Almost DNF’d 😬🕊️ ⚠️ Trigger Warnings This book features: 🩸 Illness and death 🐕 Animal death (major emotional focus) 💭 Suicidal ideation ⚠️ Child abuse 🧠 Dementia 💔 Loss, grief, and end-of-life themes 🏳️‍🌈 Antigay bias Please read with care if any of these topics are tough for you. 💛 🧠 My Thoughts Before the Summary This is going to be the most honest review I’ve written in a while. When the Cranes Fly South is one of those extremely poignant stories that everyone seems to love — highly rated, adored by many of my friends, described as “beautiful” and “devastating” and “a must-read.” And yet… I genuinely considered DNFing it. And I rarely DNF books. Like, ever . Maybe once in my life. Why? A few reasons: 1. This book is SAD with a capital S. I don’t shy away from sad books, but this is the kind of slow, quiet sadness that settles into your chest and doesn’t leave. 2. It’s ve...
Read more

How to Read a Book by Monica Wood

-
Image
📚 How to Read a Book by Monica Wood ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4/5) 👉 Grab How to Read a Book on Amazon ⚠️ Trigger Warnings Mentions of sexual assault Child abuse references Grief, death, and incarceration First Impressions 💭 When I first cracked this book open, I thought: a novel called How to Read a Book? Sounds like it might be…dry. But Monica Wood could probably write about watching paint dry and make it fascinating. Her writing is that good. I was pulled in before I even realized it. My only gripe (and the reason this is a 4-star instead of 5-star) is the amount of detail about training birds. Don’t get me wrong — it was interesting! But it sometimes felt like I accidentally wandered into another novel called How to Train a Parrot . 🦜 📖 Spoiler-Filled Plot Summary The story weaves together three POVs: Violet 👩‍🦰 A 22-year-old serving time for vehicular manslaughter after a tragic, drug-fueled crash killed Lorraine Daigle. In prison, she joins a Book Club led ...
Read more

Soldier Sailor by Claire Kilroy

-
Image
 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Soldier Sailor — Motherhood Without the Filter (5 Stars) Author: Soldier Sailor by Claire Kilroy Genre: Literary Fiction / Motherhood / Marriage ⚠️ TRIGGER WARNINGS Postpartum depression & maternal mental health Sleep deprivation Marital conflict Emotional neglect Brief child endangerment Illness in a child Death of a pet Near-drowning Intrusive thoughts Misogyny & gendered labor imbalance 🚨 FULL SPOILER WARNING 🚨 This review contains a complete plot summary, including the ending . If you want to experience this raw, gut-punch of a book unspoiled, stop here and go read it first. I’ll wait. ☕📖 A Brutally Honest Portrait of Early Motherhood Let’s just get this out of the way: Soldier Sailor is one of the most honest depictions of early motherhood I’ve ever read. No soft lighting. No Instagram glow. No “cherish every moment” nonsense. This book says the quiet part out loud: new motherhood can be isolating, terrifying, ra...
Read more

Oxford Blood by Rachael Davis Featherstone

-
Image
Oxford Blood by Rachael Davis Featherstone ⭐⭐⭐½ (3.5/5) 🩸📚 Dark Academia | Murder Mystery | Oxford Secrets Welcome back to SPOILEDBOOKS.BLOGSPOT.COM , where we absolutely do spill the plot — and today we’re heading straight into the blood-soaked quads of Oxford. This one is intense , layered , and dripping in dark academia vibes . I was hooked early… and then slowly started to feel the weight of one too many layers . Let’s get into it. 🚨 SPOILER WARNING 🚨 This review contains FULL spoilers, including the ending. Proceed only if you’re ready to know who did it, why they did it, and how deep Oxford’s sins really go. ⚠️ Trigger Warnings Murder Death of a romantic partner Racism & classism Sexual assault (off-page discussion) Drugging Emotional manipulation Institutional corruption Violence 🏛️ Dark Academia, But Make It Personal Oxford Blood follows Eva Dawkins , a smart, hardworking, biracial student from a disadvantaged background who’s interviewing for English at Oxford’s Bee...
Read more

Julie Chan Is Dead by Liann Zhang

-
Image
⭐ Julie Chan Is Dead — 4.5/5 Stars | Dark, Hilarious, Influencer Chaos at Its Best ⚠️ Trigger Warnings illness • death • pregnancy loss • animal cruelty • suicide • racism • substance use • sexual content • psychological abuse • cult-like behavior 😄 My Spoiler-Filled, Chaos-Loving Review “I even forgot the PLU code for bananas.” THE WAY I HOWLED. If you've ever worked as a cashier, you felt this in your soul. Banana 4011 is forever burned into my brain (along with carpal-tunnel nightmares and the smell of old conveyor belts). This book gets it . Anyway — I really loved this one. It’s sharp, funny, slightly unhinged, and a perfect takedown of influencer culture. But I do have questions: 👉 Why did the police immediately assume the body was Julie? It’s literally found in Chloe’s home. And they know the twins are identical! Wouldn’t… you know… someone double-check? A driver’s license? A fingerprint? A pulse? ANYTHING? 😂 But aside from that logic wobble, this book is suc...
Read more

Audition by Katie Kitamura

-
Image
🎭 Audition by Katie Kitamura — ⭐️⭐️⭐️💫 (3.5/5) 🛒 Buy Audition on Amazon (affiliate link) ⚠️ Trigger Warnings Pregnancy loss, abortion, emotional abuse, elder abuse, relationship tension, and grief. 💬 My Thoughts Some books feel like entertainment. Others feel like an experience . Audition falls firmly into the second category. Katie Kitamura writes in a way that’s hard to describe — it’s controlled, elegant, and quietly unsettling. The story moves slowly, but it absorbs you. You don’t just read it — you live inside it for a while. The premise sounds deceptively simple: an actress preparing for a new stage role meets a young man named Xavier, who claims to be her son. From there, the story morphs into something much stranger and deeper — about identity, performance, and the thin line between truth and illusion. I can’t say I fully understood it, and I’m not even sure it’s meant to be fully understood. It’s layered and cerebral, and at times it felt a little too “hig...
Read more