All the Way Gone by Joanna Schaffhausen

 

---

All the Way Gone ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4/5 stars)

Detective Annalisa Vega #4 by Joanna Schaffhausen

Buckle up, because All the Way Gone is one of those books where everything is happening… all at once… and somehow it (mostly) works. 😅🔪

This fourth installment in the Detective Annalisa Vega series leans hard into moral gray areas, psychological warfare, and the unsettling question: can a sociopath ever be “good”? Short answer: absolutely not. Longer answer: keep reading.

---

⚠️ Trigger Warnings

• Murder

• Sexual assault & rape

• Arson

• Kidnapping

• Psychological manipulation

• Child endangerment

• Suicide (staged and real)

• Medical trauma

---

🚨 SPOILER WARNING 🚨

This review contains FULL, COMPLETE SPOILERS including the ending.

---

🧠 What Is All the Way Gone About?

Former Chicago detective Annalisa Vega, now running her own PI firm, Vista Investigations, takes on a case that sounds deceptively simple: an apparent accidental fall from a balcony.

The victim, Vicki Albright, died after falling from her fourteenth-floor apartment. Her death is ruled an accident—until Mara Delaney, author of the controversial book The Good Sociopath, hires Annalisa to quietly investigate.

Mara’s book centers on neurosurgeon Craig Canning, a diagnosed sociopath she publicly labels a “good” one because he saves lives. But Mara insists that if Canning did kill Vicki, Annalisa needs to prove it—while also making sure Canning never knows she asked.

🚩 Nothing suspicious about that at all, right?

---

🔔 Wind Chimes, Alibis, and a Very Convincing Red Herring

Annalisa uncovers a disturbing pattern:

• Wind chimes appear at multiple crime-adjacent locations

• A missing crystal charm becomes a potential trophy

• Witness timelines don’t line up

Annalisa even develops a credible theory explaining how Canning could have murdered Vicki by manipulating Ruth Bernstein’s clock, entering through her apartment, and creating himself an airtight hospital alibi.

Here’s the key thing though:
👉 This theory is plausible — but wrong.

And that’s what makes this book so good.

---

😈 The Real Truth: Mara Delaney Did It

In the final act, the book pulls the rug out from under us:

Craig Canning did NOT murder Vicki Albright.

Instead:

• Mara Delaney drugged and sexually assaulted Vicki herself

• She deliberately mimicked Canning’s known behavior patterns

• Then she pushed Vicki off the balcony

• All of it was done to frame Canning as part of a long, meticulously planned revenge

Mara isn’t just an author studying sociopathy.
She is a sociopath.
And not the “high-functioning surgeon” kind—the cold, trophy-collecting, identity-shifting kind.

---

🧩 Why Mara Wanted Canning Destroyed

We learn that:

• Mara and Canning were both subjects in a university sociopathy study

• Canning’s actions cost Mara an Oxford scholarship years earlier

• Mara has been manipulating identities (including posing as “Donna”) and people for years

• Her book wasn’t academic—it was weaponized revenge

Canning was dangerous, arrogant, and abusive. But Mara was methodical, patient, and far more lethal.

---

🧨 The Final Dominoes

• Canning is later found dead in what appears to be a suicide

• Annalisa realizes Mara murdered him as well

• Mara herself is ultimately found hanged, her own death echoing her crimes

Justice, but the bleak kind.

---

👨‍👩‍👧 Side Plot Clarification: Who Is Summer Weaver?

This book also runs a heavy emotional subplot involving Annalisa’s family:

Summer Weaver is Cassidy’s mother and Nick Carelli’s ex-wife. She’s hospitalized during the investigation, later wakes briefly, and ultimately passes away, adding emotional weight to:

• Cassidy’s custody uncertainty

• Nick’s strained relationships

• Annalisa stepping more firmly into a parental role

This subplot matters because it raises the stakes personally while Annalisa is dealing with predators professionally.

---

📝 Final Thoughts

Yes, this book has a LOT going on.
Yes, I felt some fatigue juggling:

• Multiple investigations

• Family drama

• Psychological chess matches

But the twist is earned, the villain reveal is excellent, and the moral ambiguity is deliciously uncomfortable.

⭐ Final Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

Not perfect. Definitely crowded.
But smart, unsettling, and absolutely worth the ride.

---

📚 If You Liked All the Way Gone, Try:

• The Good Daughter by Karin Slaughter

• False Witness by Karin Slaughter

• The Night She Disappeared by Lisa Jewell

• Before She Disappeared by Lisa Gardner

• You Will Never See Me by Jake Hinkson