The Orphanage by the Lake by Daniel G. Miller

-

 

The Orphanage by the Lake — ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆ (4/5 Stars)

A Dark, Twisty Thriller That Didn’t Deserve the Goodreads Pile‑On

⚠️ TRIGGER WARNINGS

  • Sexual assault / rape (on-page discussion)

  • Drugging

  • Human trafficking & pedophilia

  • Graphic violence

  • Murder

  • Death by suicide

  • Racism

  • Physical & emotional abuse

Read with care — this one goes to some very dark places. 🖤

🚨 SPOILER WARNING

This review contains a FULL PLOT SUMMARY with spoilers and the ending. If you want to go in blind, bookmark this and come back later.

📖 Overview

The Orphanage by the Lake (2024) is a psychological thriller by Daniel G. Miller that follows a struggling private investigator pulled into a missing‑girl case tied to a powerful orphanage in upstate New York.

And listen — people are being harsh on Goodreads about this one. 😅 I get that it’s dark, uncomfortable, and not reinventing the thriller wheel, but I genuinely thought it was solid, creepy, and engaging.

We have:

  • A law school dropout PI with trauma

  • A creepy lakeside orphanage

  • Missing girls 👀

  • Corrupt authority figures

  • And red herrings absolutely everywhere

Honestly? I was entertained.

🕵️‍♀️ Meet Hazel Cho (Flawed, Broke, and Still Trying)

Our main character, Hazel Cho, is a private investigator barely keeping her head above water in Manhattan. She dropped out of law school after being drugged and raped, and when she tried to report it… no one cared. 😡

She’s broke, emotionally scarred, and deeply cynical — which made her feel very real to me.

When wealthy socialite Madeline Hemsley walks into Hazel’s office and offers $100,000 to find her missing goddaughter Mia, Hazel knows it’s too good to be true.

Spoiler: it absolutely is.

🏚️ The Orphanage by the Lake (aka Nightmare Fuel)

Mia disappeared from Saint Agnes, a Gothic orphanage on Lake George, six months earlier. Police investigations went nowhere. Other PIs failed. Hazel heads north and immediately realizes something is off.

Over the course of her investigation, Hazel suspects:

  • The headmaster 🧑‍🏫

  • The music teacher 🎶

  • The security manager 🔐

  • The police 👮

  • Rich donors 💰

  • Basically… everyone

There’s a strange Dionysus symbol, whispers of other missing girls, and a whole lot of powerful people protecting Saint Agnes.

Classic thriller setup — and honestly, a fun one.

🧩 Red Herrings, Secrets, and Escalating Danger

Hazel uncovers articles about multiple girls who vanished from Saint Agnes over the years. She’s warned to stop digging. She’s attacked. She realizes some of the people threatening her are police officers.

At the same time, her personal life complicates things:

  • Her best friend and roommate Kenny (a future cop) worries she’s in danger

  • She begins dating charming, wealthy Andrew DuPont (🚩🚩🚩)

Meanwhile, Madeline finally confesses the truth:
➡️ Mia isn’t her goddaughter — she’s her daughter.

Madeline’s racist family forced her to give Mia up because Mia’s father is Black. Yes, it’s as ugly as it sounds.

😬 The Twist (Not Shocking, But Satisfying)

If you read a lot of thrillers, the final reveal probably won’t floor you — it didn’t for me. But I was still satisfied.

Andrew DuPont is revealed to be running the Dionysus Theater, a trafficking operation where underaged girls are drugged and exploited for wealthy men. Mia is being held there.

Andrew only dated Hazel to monitor her investigation.

When Hazel learns the truth, Andrew locks her up and prepares to assault and kill her. Then comes the real gut punch:

➡️ Sonia Barreto, the warm and welcoming orphanage director, is involved too.

Hazel kills Andrew in self-defense. Sonia tortures Hazel. Kenny calls the police. The operation is shut down. The girls are rescued.

Dark? Yes.

Effective? Also yes.

🏁 The Ending

Two weeks later:

  • Mia is reunited with her mother

  • Sonia and the others are arrested

  • Hazel earns her $100,000 fee

  • She officially hires Kenny as her assistant

No fairy‑tale ending — but justice, survival, and a sense of hard‑won closure.

⭐ Final Thoughts

Is this the most shocking thriller I’ve ever read? No.

Is it dark, uncomfortable, and sometimes brutal? Absolutely.

But I thought The Orphanage by the Lake was:

  • Well-paced

  • Easy to binge

  • Loaded with tension

  • And anchored by a compelling, damaged protagonist

Maybe I’m desensitized after reading a lot of thrillers — but I had a good time with this one.

⭐ 4 out of 5 stars

📚 If You Liked This, Try:

  • The Night She Disappeared by Lisa Jewell

  • The Girl in the Lake by India Rigsby

  • Never Lie by Freida McFadden

  • The Butterfly Garden by Dot Hutchison

  • The Quiet Tenant by Clémence Michallon

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular Posts This Week!

Normal People by Sally Rooney

-
Image
⭐ Book Review: Normal People by Sally Rooney 👉 Grab your copy of Normal People on Amazon (affiliate link) ⚠️ Trigger Warnings This book isn’t heavy on action, but it is heavy on feelings. Here are the trigger warnings : Abuse / Domestic Violence (emotional and physical) Toxic relationships Bullying Depression & Mental Health Struggles Suicide (off-page but impactful) Gaslighting & Miscommunication (honestly the biggest villain of this book 👀) 📖 Quick Take Normal People is one of those books that’s brilliantly written but hard to rate . Like… did I love it? Did I want to shake every character by the shoulders? Yes, and yes. There’s no traditional climax or neat little bow at the end. Instead, Sally Rooney gives us two extremely believable characters— so believable they’re frustrating —whose relationship is propelled almost entirely by miscommunication . Nothing “big” happens… and yet I couldn’t stop reading. It’s honestly kind of impress...
Read more

Bat Eater and Other Names for Cora Zeng by Kylie Lee Baker

-
Image
⭐ 5/5 Review: Bat Eater and Other Names for Cora Zeng — Jiangshi , Justice, and Pandemic-Era Rage 🦇👻 👉 Grab Bat Eater and Other Names for Cora Zeng on Amazon 📚 (affiliate link) ⚠️ Content & Trigger Warnings Racism / xenophobia (COVID-era) 😷 Graphic violence & murder 💀 Sexual harassment / assault (mentioned) Child abuse & death 🧸 Suicidal ideation & mental illness Animal cruelty 🐈 Police corruption / cover-up First Impressions 💬 Wow. Just—wow. This is a level of horror mastery I wasn’t ready for. I went in blind (new-to-me author + didn’t even read the blurb) and got walloped by a story that’s scary, timely, and deeply personal . If you love ghost stories —specifically jiangshi from Chinese folklore—this will scratch an itch you didn’t know you still had. Growing up in China, jiangshi terrified me; decades in the U.S. made me forget that fear. This book brought it back… in the best, creepiest way. 🫣 Baker tackles COVID-e...
Read more

First Lie Wins by Ashley Elston

-
Image
  🎭 First Lie Wins by Ashley Elston – Book Review Rating:  ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ½   3.5 out of 5 stars A twisty con story that requires a seatbelt, a spreadsheet… and maybe a second read. ⚠️ Spoiler Alert! Spoilers ahead! If you’re planning to read First Lie Wins without knowing the truth behind the lies, come back later after you’ve untangled the web yourself. 🕵️‍♀️ What’s the Premise? Evie Porter isn’t who she says she is. In fact, Evie Porter doesn’t even exist. Our main character is a woman who assumes different identities for a living, taking covert assignments from a man known only as Mr. Smith —a handler who doles out new identities, objectives, and locations like he's playing puppetmaster. When we meet "Evie," she's living in a small Louisiana town, dating a rich Southern gentleman named Ryan Sumner , whose charm and mansion come with just a little too much backstory. Evie’s assignment? We’re not told upfront, because—of course—we’re on a need-to-know basis with th...
Read more

The Midnight Library by Matt Haig

-
Image
♟️ Book Review: The Midnight Library by Matt Haig ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5 stars) Affiliate link: Grab your copy of The Midnight Library on Amazon 📚 🚨 Trigger Warnings 💊 Suicide attempt / suicidal thoughts 🐈 Death of a pet (cat) 💔 Depression, grief, and loneliness 🍷 Alcohol use 🌊 Near-death experiences 😍 My Quick Take Wow. Like, capital W, underline, bold, italics — WOW. This is easily one of the best books I’ve ever read. The premise? Chef’s kiss — it’s something I’ve thought about a lot. Honestly, the book didn’t reveal anything earth-shatteringly new for me… because I already agreed with most of its conclusions. But reading it still felt like a warm hug from the universe. Also, I loved the chess metaphor running through the book — totally nailed it. And as a chess lover myself, it made my nerdy little heart happy. ♟️ ⚠️ SPOILER WARNING — Full & Complete Plot Summary Ahead If you haven’t read The Midnight Library yet and want to be surprised, sk...
Read more

Happy Wife by Meredith Lavender

-
Image
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ (4/5) — HAPPY WIFE : Age-Gap Romance, Winter Park Drama, and a Killer Who Actually Surprised Me (Kind Of) 💍🔪 ⚠️ Trigger Warnings This book contains: 💔 Domestic violence 🩸 Death and murder 💊 Substance use 💬 Sexual content 🎭 Emotional manipulation ⚖️ Toxic relationships Please read with care if any of these topics are sensitive for you. 💛 🧠 My Thoughts Before the Summary I’m honestly surprised this book’s average rating is hovering around 3.7 — in my humble opinion, that feels a tad low. I went in expecting something “fine,” and ended up having a good time. First off: I love an age-gap romance , and since I’m in one myself, maybe I’m just naturally drawn to these dynamics. So the premise — young woman meets older, wealthy, charming man — is familiar, yes, but also one of my favorite tropes when it’s done well. And here? It worked. Sure, some parts of the story felt recognizable (Winter Park social politics! Disapproving ex-wife! Secrets under immaculat...
Read more

Julie Chan Is Dead by Liann Zhang

-
Image
⭐ Julie Chan Is Dead — 4.5/5 Stars | Dark, Hilarious, Influencer Chaos at Its Best ⚠️ Trigger Warnings illness • death • pregnancy loss • animal cruelty • suicide • racism • substance use • sexual content • psychological abuse • cult-like behavior 😄 My Spoiler-Filled, Chaos-Loving Review “I even forgot the PLU code for bananas.” THE WAY I HOWLED. If you've ever worked as a cashier, you felt this in your soul. Banana 4011 is forever burned into my brain (along with carpal-tunnel nightmares and the smell of old conveyor belts). This book gets it . Anyway — I really loved this one. It’s sharp, funny, slightly unhinged, and a perfect takedown of influencer culture. But I do have questions: 👉 Why did the police immediately assume the body was Julie? It’s literally found in Chloe’s home. And they know the twins are identical! Wouldn’t… you know… someone double-check? A driver’s license? A fingerprint? A pulse? ANYTHING? 😂 But aside from that logic wobble, this book is suc...
Read more