The Fourth Turning Is Here by Neil Howe
⭐⭐ The Fourth Turning Is Here — Fascinating, Frustrating, and Honestly… Annoying (2/5 ⭐)
Author: Neil Howe
Genre: History / Sociology / Political Theory
Rating: ⭐⭐ 2 out of 5
⚠️ Trigger Warnings
Political polarization • War • Civil conflict • Economic collapse • Societal crisis • Authorial overconfidence • Repeated use of the phrase “this always happens”
🤔 Initial Thoughts: When a Book Makes You Want to Argue Back
This is one of those books that starts out making you think, Wow, this is fascinating, and slowly transitions into, Okay… I hear you… but do you have to explain literally everything this way?
Neil Howe presents a sweeping, ambitious theory about history and generational cycles, and at first, it’s genuinely captivating. I found myself nodding along, highlighting passages, and feeling impressed by the scope of it all. But as the book goes on, Howe’s absolute confidence in his framework starts to feel a little heavy-handed. Every major historical event seems to circle back to the same explanation, and eventually I found myself wanting to raise my hand and say, “Sure, but… what about literally anything else?”
I admired the boldness. I respected the intellectual effort. I also felt a growing urge to argue back — sometimes with the book, sometimes with the author in my head. It’s engaging, thought-provoking, and just frustrating enough to keep you mentally sparring until the very last page. 😅
📚 What This Book Is About (Premise)
At its core, The Fourth Turning Is Here argues that history moves in predictable cycles called saecula, each lasting roughly 80–100 years (about the length of a long human life).
Each saeculum is divided into four repeating “seasons,” or Turnings:
High (Spring) – Strong institutions, social unity, optimism 🌱
Awakening (Summer) – Cultural rebellion, spiritual upheaval ☀️
Unraveling (Fall) – Institutions weaken, individualism peaks 🍂
Crisis (Winter) – Chaos, conflict, sacrifice, rebirth ❄️🔥
These cycles are driven by four recurring generational archetypes:
Prophet, Nomad, Hero, and Artist, each aging into predictable roles.
According to Howe, we are currently deep in the Fourth Turning — the Crisis stage — and things are going to get much worse before they get better. Buckle up.
🚨 SPOILER WARNING 🚨
Full plot summary, theory breakdown, and ending below. No surprises spared.
🧠 The Full Plot (a.k.a. The Theory, Expanded and Explained)
⏳ The Saeculum Framework (The “Plot Engine”)
The book treats history like a repeating narrative arc:
A new civic order is born after a crisis
That order grows strong and complacent
A cultural rebellion challenges it
Institutions decay
Everything collapses spectacularly
Rinse. Repeat.
According to Howe, this cycle is inevitable and predictable. (Yes, he is very confident about this.)
❄️ The Current Crisis: The Millennial Fourth Turning
Howe claims the current Crisis began around 2008, triggered by the Global Financial Crisis, which ended the Unraveling era.
Key milestones:
Precursor: Post-9/11 unity (short-lived)
Catalyst: 2008 financial collapse
First Regeneracy: 2016 election → red vs. blue polarization 🇺🇸⚔️
From here, Howe argues we are heading toward the most intense phase of the Crisis: the Ekpyrosis (yes, that’s really the word he uses).
🔥 The Ekpyrosis (The Big Scary Ending)
This is the climax of the Fourth Turning, expected around 2030, involving:
Massive collective mobilization
Trauma, sacrifice, and upheaval
A violent or existential conflict
Howe presents three possible paths:
Internal conflict (civil war–style polarization)
External war (a unified nation vs. a global enemy)
Political realignment that leads to one of the above anyway
No matter which path occurs, Howe insists:
➡️ It will be painful
➡️ Institutions will be rebuilt from the ground up
➡️ A new American civic order will emerge
🌅 The Ending: A New American “High”
After the Crisis resolves (around 2033), the book ends on a hopeful note:
A new First Turning begins
Society becomes more unified
Institutions strengthen
Economic prosperity returns
Generations fall neatly into their next roles:
Millennials (Heroes): Institution-builders 🏗️
Homelanders (Artists): Cooperative experts 🤝
New Prophets: Protected children who will later rebel (of course)
And thus… the cycle begins again. The end. 🔁
😬 Where the Book Starts to Fall Apart
Here’s my problem: Howe makes his theory do too much heavy lifting.
Over and over, historical events are explained almost exclusively through generational cycles, while other massive forces get brushed aside.
Examples that made me sigh deeply:
Women’s rights movement: Attributed mainly to generational awakening… while barely acknowledging birth control, which completely changed women’s autonomy.
Civil War: Framed as generational destiny, with minimal attention to industrialization, economic interests, and global trade pressures.
At some point, it starts to feel like confirmation bias on steroids. If history doesn’t fit the theory, the theory doesn’t bend — history does.
⚖️ Final Verdict: So… Did I Like It?
Honestly? I have mixed feelings.
👍 What Worked:
Bold, fascinating framework
Forces you to think big-picture
The idea of recurring cycles is compelling
👎 What Didn’t:
Overconfidence bordering on dogma
Cherry-picked history
Oversimplification of complex events
A little too much “this always happens” energy 🙃
I don’t not recommend this book… but yes, it annoyed me quite a bit.
⭐ Final Rating: 2 out of 5 stars
Worth reading for the ideas. Just… take it with a very large grain of salt 🧂🧂🧂
📚 If You’re Interested in Big Ideas Like This, Try These Instead:
Sapiens by Yuval Noah Harari
The Dawn of Everything by David Graeber & David Wengrow
Guns, Germs, and Steel by Jared Diamond
Why Nations Fail by Daron Acemoglu & James A. Robinson
💬 Bottom line:
The Fourth Turning Is Here will absolutely get you thinking — and possibly arguing — which might be its greatest strength and its biggest flaw.
Comments
Post a Comment