Still Life by Louise Penny
🎯 Still Life by Louise Penny — Book Review (⭐ 5/5)
⚠️ SPOILER WARNING:
If you don’t want to know whodunit, stop here — because I’m about to break down every twist, turn, and secret in this cozy-yet-dark mystery!
🏡 Welcome to Three Pines — A Village That’s Almost Too Quiet
Three Pines looks like the kind of place where nothing bad ever happens: charming, peaceful, full of quirky neighbors. But then… Jane Neal, a sweet 76-year-old retired teacher, turns up dead in the woods on Thanksgiving weekend — killed by an arrow.
Was it a hunting accident, or is something much more sinister going on?
👮 Chief Inspector Gamache to the Rescue
Armand Gamache, head of homicide at the Sûreté du Québec, arrives to investigate — thoughtful, kind, and actually willing to listen (a rarity in fictional detectives). His team:
✔️ Jean Guy Beauvoir — sharp, loyal second-in-command
✔️ Yvette Nichol — new agent who’s eager but makes everything harder
🕵️ The Suspects and Secrets Start Piling Up
👉 Ben Hadley — runs the archery club and found Jane’s body. Arrows? Yeah, that looks bad.
👉 Yolande Fontaine — Jane’s niece. Bitter, greedy, blocks the cops from searching Jane’s house, clearly after the inheritance money.
👉 The Crofts — their son has a sketchy hunting history, and Jane’s blood is found on their property.
Meanwhile, Jane’s house is a mystery of its own: no one’s ever been past her kitchen.
🎨 Jane’s Art Reveals the Truth
Gamache finally gets inside Jane’s home and discovers:
✨ Hidden art all over the walls, covered for years by Yolande’s hideous wallpaper.
✨ A painting called Fair Day — a snapshot of the parade from the county fair, the same day Ben’s mother died.
Here’s where it clicks:
➡ Ben had always claimed he wasn’t in town on parade day — it was his alibi for his mother’s death.
➡ But Fair Day shows Ben in the parade crowd.
➡ When Ben saw Jane’s painting, he realized it could expose his lie and make him look very guilty.
So he painted over his own face to erase the proof — and killed Jane to silence her.
💥 The Showdown
Clara (Jane’s best friend) spots the tampered painting at the art exhibit. She puts the pieces together and confronts Ben — who traps her in his basement, ready to kill again.
Gamache races in, saves Clara, and gets injured in the process (because no cozy mystery is complete without a little drama).
💡 What Actually Happened
🔹 Ben killed his mother when she planned to cut his inheritance.
🔹 Jane’s painting unintentionally exposed his lie about not being in town that day.
🔹 Ben panicked, tried to cover his tracks, and killed Jane.
Gamache, ever the hero, solves the case.
✨ Why I Loved It
✔️ The blend of cozy village life and dark secrets
✔️ Gamache is such a refreshing, humane detective
✔️ The art-as-clue angle was original and meaningful
✔️ A twist that was logical and surprising
📌 Where to Buy Still Life
😍 If You Enjoyed This, Check Out:
👉 A Great Reckoning by Louise Penny — another fantastic Gamache novel
👉 The No. 1 Ladies’ Detective Agency by Alexander McCall Smith — different setting, same warmth
👉 The Thursday Murder Club by Richard Osman — small town, big secrets
🌟 Final Thoughts
I gave Still Life 5 stars — this is the perfect start to a series that blends clever mysteries with rich characters and atmosphere. If you like your crime fiction heartfelt and smart, Still Life belongs on your shelf.
Comments
Post a Comment