📚 The Story She Left Behind by Patti Callahan Henry - She Left Her Kid in a Fire and We're Supposed to Root for Her?!
⭐️⭐️ (2 out of 5 stars)
🏡 It begins with a fire...
The story opens in 1927, Bluffton, South Carolina, with a shocking event: Bronwyn Newcastle Fordham accidentally sets her house on fire. She manages to get her 8-year-old daughter, Clara, out—but not before Clara is severely burned. A fireman loses his life.
Then Bronwyn disappears. No note, no explanation. She vanishes, leaving her daughter Clara and her husband Timothy behind.
Let me just say—this is where the book lost me a little. More on that later.
🎨 Fast-forward 25 years...
Clara is now an art teacher and a single mom to her daughter, Wynnie. She's accomplished in her own right, having just won the Caldecott Medal for children’s book illustration.
But she’s still living in the shadow of the mother who abandoned her—Bronwyn, who at age 12 wrote a wildly famous children’s book called The Middle Place.
Clara holds onto a never-published sequel that Bronwyn wrote in a secret invented language—a manuscript that no one has ever been able to decode.
📞 Enter: The Mysterious Call from England
One day, a man named Charlie Jameson calls from London. While going through his late father's belongings, he found something shocking:
✨ A dictionary of Bronwyn’s invented language,
✨ A bundle of letters addressed to Clara,
✨ And a connection between their families.
Could this finally be the key to unlocking the sequel—and the past?
Clara and Wynnie head to England.
🚙 A literal twist in the road...
On the way to Charlie’s family summer house in Cumbria, they pick up a woman who claims to need help with directions.
Instead, she robs them, stealing:
-
Bronwyn’s satchel
-
Clara and Wynnie’s passports
-
And possibly, the only copy of the precious dictionary
She then throws herself out of the moving car (yes, really).
Clara chases her down but only recovers a few pages. The dictionary is gone. 💔
🌿 New life, old secrets
In Cumbria, Clara tries to move forward. She and Wynnie settle into life with the Jamesons—walking, drawing, talking. Clara and Charlie begin to fall for each other.
Charlie even asks:
“Would you consider staying here? With me?”
Clara is torn. She still needs closure. What really happened to her mother?
😲 Plot twist: Bronwyn is alive
Charlie takes Clara to meet a mysterious woman named Isolde, who turns out to be...
Bronwyn.
She’s been alive this whole time, living under a fake identity. She tells Clara:
-
She fled after the fire because of trauma and psychiatric abuse
-
Charlie’s father, Callum, was the only person she trusted
-
He helped hide her in England
❤️ Forgiveness & Fresh Starts
Clara is devastated and angry—but also relieved. She calls Timothy, who soon arrives in England. He and Bronwyn rekindle their relationship.
Over the next few days, Clara and Bronwyn confront the past and try to heal.
Eventually, Clara chooses to forgive—and to stay in Cumbria with Charlie and her new/old family.
🔥 Final Chapter: Letting Go
The book ends in 1962. Clara, Bronwyn, and Wynnie rewrite Bronwyn’s lost sequel together.
Then, they take the original, indecipherable manuscript, burn it, and scatter the ashes by the lake. 🌅
🧠 My Thoughts
Here’s the deal:
I loved the writing style. Patti Callahan Henry has a lovely, lyrical way of describing setting and emotion. The English countryside was especially vivid.
But…
❌ I couldn’t get past Bronwyn’s choice.
As a mom of two daughters, I couldn’t relate to a woman who would just vanish—leaving behind her child and husband with no explanation. I understand the book tries to justify it with mental illness and trauma, but for me, it just didn’t work.
There was no redemption arc strong enough to erase 25 years of abandonment.
📝 Final Verdict
-
Writing style: Gorgeous
-
Setting: Atmospheric
-
Plot twist: Interesting
-
Main character’s decision? Nope. Just nope.
⭐️⭐️ out of 5 stars
Comments
Post a Comment