💙 The Blue Hour by Paula Hawkins – A Sculpted Mystery with a Bleak Afterglow
Rating: ⭐⭐½ (2.5/5)
Genre: Literary Mystery / Suspense
Themes: Obsession • Art • Betrayal • Death
Tone: Slow-Burning • Bleak • Psychological
🌌 First Impressions
The title The Blue Hour immediately drew me in. If you’ve ever watched the sky turn a moody blue after the sun sets or just before it rises — that in-between, almost magic hour — you know it’s beautiful but eerie. The kind of beauty that tricks you into forgetting something’s missing. That’s the vibe of this novel. It’s all about illusions, and what’s lurking beneath what we call art, love, and even friendship.
Sounds poetic, right?
Unfortunately... the execution didn’t quite live up to the concept. It started with an intriguing mystery — a human bone hidden in a famous sculpture — but the story veers into unnecessarily dense territory and spends a bit too much time trudging through diary entries and foggy motivations.
🖼️ Plot Summary (Spoiler Alert)
Renowned artist Vanessa Chapman has died, and her artwork is now being curated by the Fairburn Foundation. One of her pieces — a sculpture called The Blue Hour — contains something unexpected: a real human bone.
Enter James Becker, a curator at the foundation who’s tasked with looking into the sculpture’s origins. He checks in with Emmeline Lennox, wife of the late gallery owner Douglas Lennox. Emmeline is manipulative, ambitious, and — plot twist — responsible for her husband’s death. But that’s not our main mystery.
The sculpture dates back to the time Vanessa’s husband, Julian, went missing. So Becker starts asking uncomfortable questions. His investigation leads him to a remote island where Grace, Vanessa’s best friend (and executor of her estate), lives.
And this is where things take a dark, sinister turn. Over time, Becker uncovers the horrifying truth: Grace murdered not just Julian, but also Vanessa, and another mutual friend named Nick Riley. Her motive? Twisted obsession, abandonment issues, and a toxic cocktail of possessiveness and mental illness. Oh, and did I mention Grace is a doctor? So she has access to plenty of morphine.
Here's the kicker: Grace never meant for the bone to end up in Vanessa’s artwork. Vanessa found it in the woods near their cottage and assumed it was from an animal. Grace later "mercifully" killed Vanessa when she was dying of cancer. (Or so she says...)
When Becker pieces it all together, Grace drugs him, shoves him in a car, and drives it into the ocean.
The last image is haunting — blue light flooding his vision. Some readers think it's a police rescue. I think it's the final light he sees as he drowns. It mirrors the book’s title in the most tragic, poetic way possible.
💭 Final Thoughts
While the premise was gripping, the execution didn’t land for me. The pacing dragged, the plot was overcomplicated, and the story lacked emotional punch. It had all the makings of a great psychological mystery, but it ended up feeling like a character study of miserable people doing miserable things.
If you're into slow-burn stories with morally gray characters, you might appreciate the atmosphere. But personally? I felt like I was reading through fog.
📚 You Might Also Like...
If you liked the themes of hidden secrets, obsession, and identity but want something with a bit more payoff, try these instead:
-
The Paper Palace by Miranda Cowley Heller – A raw, emotionally layered mystery built around a woman’s past and a fateful choice.
-
Sharp Objects by Gillian Flynn – Creepy small-town secrets, unreliable women, and twisted mother-daughter relationships.
-
The Sculptor by Michael Whelan – An under-the-radar mystery with art, death, and a descent into madness.
-
The Girl Before by JP Delaney – A psychological thriller with an eerie home, manipulative characters, and a slow-burn unraveling.
🛒 Where to Buy
Let me know if you’ve read The Blue Hour! Did the ending hit you emotionally, or were you left in the dark like me? 💀 Let’s chat in the comments!
Comments
Post a Comment