Men We Reaped by Jesmyn Ward

 

---

💔 Men We Reaped by Jesmyn Ward – A Memoir That Didn't Land For Me

[⭐️⭐️ 2 out of 5 stars]

➤ Buy Men We Reaped:

📚 Amazon

---

✏️ First Impressions

Have you ever picked up a book that you wanted to love — because the author is brilliant and the subject matter is important — but it just didn’t connect? That was my experience with Men We Reaped by Jesmyn Ward.

Ward is an incredibly gifted writer — no question about it — and her story is deeply personal and tragic. But despite the rawness, the book didn’t bring out the emotional reaction I was expecting. Instead of sympathy, I mostly felt frustrated.

---

📖 What's It About?

Jesmyn Ward tells the story of five men in her life who died young, including her younger brother, Joshua. These men — friends, cousins, neighbors — all passed away between 2000 and 2004, most of them under heartbreaking circumstances.

The memoir uses two interwoven timelines:

• One moves forward, chronicling Jesmyn’s life from childhood in DeLisle, Mississippi — a rural, impoverished, predominantly Black town.

• The other moves backward, recounting the deaths of these five men in reverse order, starting with the most recent and moving toward her brother’s death.

Eventually, both timelines meet in the center — at Joshua’s passing, which is the emotional climax of the book.

---

⚖️ What Worked… and What Didn’t (For Me)

Let me be clear: Ward’s writing is powerful. Her pain is palpable. She doesn't shy away from the harsh truths about racism, poverty, and how society neglects Black communities in the rural South.

But here’s where it lost me:

• There’s a pattern of trauma, grief, and substance use that repeats with little reflection or change in behavior from the people around her.

• The book doesn’t quite explore personal responsibility, even while acknowledging systemic injustice. It left me wanting more depth on how people cope, grieve, or grow — not just succumb to the cycle.

I found myself thinking, Okay, but why did no one do anything differently? Even when circumstances were brutally hard, choosing to drink, use, or fight after a funeral doesn’t feel like it should be the only option. Maybe that’s the point — that it feels like there aren’t options. Still, that hopelessness felt repetitive and emotionally numbing instead of enlightening.

---

💬 Some Brutally Honest Thoughts

“I don’t think I’m heartless... but I definitely finished this book with more frustration than sympathy.”

I know, that sounds harsh. But when every death is followed by more partying, more substance abuse, more silence — it’s hard not to feel like we’re stuck in place, not moving toward insight or healing.

That said, I do believe Ward is a force. Her writing has an urgency and intelligence that shines even through my disconnect with the narrative. I can absolutely see why this book resonates with many readers — it just wasn’t for me.

---

🛠️ Final Verdict

A memoir that’s deeply personal, beautifully written, and undeniably important — but emotionally disconnected me. I wanted to be devastated. Instead, I was just... stuck. I admire Jesmyn Ward as a writer and a survivor, but this story left me cold instead of cracked open.

⭐️⭐️ 2 out of 5 stars.

---

📚 If You Liked This (Or Wanted To), Try These Instead:

• Heavy by Kiese Laymon
   💬 A memoir about race, trauma, and growing up in Mississippi — beautifully written and brutally honest.
   🔗 Buy on Amazon

• The Glass Castle by Jeannette Walls
   🏚️ A raw account of poverty and resilience — more introspective, with a similar thread of surviving childhood.
   🔗 Buy on Amazon

• Between the World and Me by Ta-Nehisi Coates
   📜 More philosophical and lyrical, offering a wider lens on Black life in America.
   🔗 Buy on Amazon

---

Do you ever finish a book and then immediately Google: "Is it okay that I didn’t like this critically acclaimed book?" If so, you’re not alone — and you’re always welcome here. Let's talk about it. 💬